The Key Lime Pie Factory is the very place, according to the plaque next to the entrance, where the iconic dessert was first conceived in 1856. By American standards, this is positively prehistoric. If questioned, the proprietors would probably insist that it had been made with dinosaur milk by pilgrims donning starched aprons and white bonnets, outcast from the Olde Worlde for their…erm… pieous beliefs.
The verdict?
As you can see, this is one fine-looking Key lime pie. Akin to a catwalk model of the 90’s everything’s in perfect proportion – crust, filling, cream topping. Consistency and texture are just how they ought to be. Couldn’t fault it, try as I might. Hmmm…. if pushed at gun point, I’d whisper through clenched teeth that, perhaps, it was a teensy weensy itsy bitsy too tart for me…
My rating: 4.5 out of 5.
Missed the other reviews? Here they are:
And if you want to know how my cake obsession started, click here. [Warning – contains hideous photographs of 70’s and 80’s fashion].
Wow, American snark AND a pie pun? This is delightful 🙂
LikeLike
The distress of packing and having to leave this beautiful island in a few hours brings it out…
LikeLike
I can get on board with this pie. Nearly naked except for a dainty, modest covering of whipped cream.
With all these key lime pie talk, I’m getting a hankering for Steve’s Key Lime here in Brooklyn. I’ll have to go soon.
LikeLike
We Want Pictures!
LikeLike
Pieous – you’ve surpassed yourself 😉 Will there ever be a 5, I wonder!?
LikeLike
There is…! Will write it up when I get back home.
LikeLike
Oooh, exciting!
LikeLike
Who needs to hit 100% Then there would be no reason to continue the quest! And, no surprise, the best was clearly left to last! Happy journeys home and recovering from your key lime pie adventures!
LikeLike
The journey home won’t be a happy one… I don’t want to leave!!! Too many pies left untried 😉
LikeLike
Time to get another obsession… clearly! 🙂
As for me, plowing into morning feasting in Kuala Lumpur!
LikeLike
I prefer an itsy bitsy too tart pie to one that’s “empalagoso”.
Safe travels!
LikeLike
My first one was empalagoso… urgh… 😦
LikeLike
This sounds like the one for me! Oh, it’s making me hungry!
LikeLike
There’s two more to come… you wait 😉
LikeLike
That is a fine-looking slice. The crust is so perfect! Will you declare the ultimate winner in the Pie Superbowl?
LikeLike
now do you know what I like about your reviews? Well four “S’s” come to mind – They are simple and short – but also worded with seasoned experience. And filled with your unique style – with your play on words –
“it was a teensy weensy itsy bitsy too tart…”
but really love the succinctness most –
LikeLike
Thanks 🙂 I like to keep it short if I can… whenever I see a post in my reader that’s 1k+ of wordage, I deliberate on whether to click on it or not….
LikeLike